Greetings:
I'm brand new to Python and decided to write a syllogism solver for a
class I'm taking. At the start of the program, I define a function that
classifies the type of each statement in the syllogism. Python tells me
that it is expecting an indented block at the s in "some". I can see
what I'm doing wrong. Here's the code:
def class_stmt(q,c):
"""
This function classifies a statement according to the rules of
categorical syllogisms and returns A, E, I, to identify the
statement type.
"""
if q.lower() == "all":
if "not" in c:
stmt_type = "E"
else:
stmt_type = "A"
elif q.lower() == "some" # s in some is highlighted
if "not" in c:
stmt_type = ""
else:
stmt_type = "I"
elif q.lower() == "no":
if "not" in c:
stmt_type = "A"
else:
stmt_type = "E"
else:
if "not" in c:
stmt_type = "E"
else:
stmt_type = "A"
return stmt_type
Any ideas? Thanks in advance.
Keith

kagard (AT) gmail (DOT) com wrote:
Greetings:
<snip>
elif q.lower() == "some" # s in some is highlighted
<snip>
Any ideas? Thanks in advance.
Keith
Would the missing colon have something to do with it?
elif q.lower() == "some":

alisonken1 wrote:
kagard (AT) gmail (DOT) com wrote:
Greetings:

<snip>
elif q.lower() == "some" # s in some is highlighted
<snip>
Any ideas? Thanks in advance.

Keith

Would the missing colon have something to do with it?

elif q.lower() == "some":

Thanks for the replies:

I'm sorry, the colon is there in the original, I accidentally blew it
off when I added the comment. The only information I get from IDLE is a
dialog box that says:

Syntax Error
There's an error in your program:
expected an indented block

Keith

Thanks for the replies:

I'm sorry, the colon is there in the original, I accidentally blew it
off when I added the comment. The only information I get from IDLE is a
dialog box that says:

Syntax Error
There's an error in your program:
expected an indented block

Keith

To see the full traceback, assuming you're using windows, you need to
run it on the Command prompt.

Dustan wrote:

To see the full traceback, assuming you're using windows, you need to
run it on the Command prompt.

Hi Dustan:

Here's the traceback:

C:\docs\Python>SylloSolver.py
File "C:\docs\Python\SylloSolver.py", line
"""
^
IndentationError: expected an indented block

I got rid of the triple quote string at the start of the function, and
that cleared up the problem, though I don't know why.

Thanks

Keith

kagard (AT) gmail (DOT) com wrote:
Dustan wrote:
--
To see the full traceback, assuming you're using windows, you need to
run it on the Command prompt.

Hi Dustan:

Here's the traceback:

C:\docs\Python>SylloSolver.py
File "C:\docs\Python\SylloSolver.py", line
"""
^
IndentationError: expected an indented block

I got rid of the triple quote string at the start of the function, and
that cleared up the problem, though I don't know why.

Thanks

Keith

Ah, yes. The docstring for a function (or at least its first
triple-quote) must be indented to the same degree as its statements.
(If you're using IDLE it should have indented it for you when you hit
return after the def statement.)

HTH,
~Simon

Simon Forman wrote:
I got rid of the triple quote string at the start of the function, and
that cleared up the problem, though I don't know why.

Ah, yes. The docstring for a function (or at least its first
triple-quote) must be indented to the same degree as its statements.
(If you're using IDLE it should have indented it for you when you hit
return after the def statement.)

HTH,
~Simon

Hi Simon:

Thanks. I code in VB / VBA, and use indented structure, but it's not
enforced they way it is in Python - still getting used to that. Also, I
got goofed up editing some of the code in VIM, indenting with tabs, and
then switching to IDLE, with space indentation. Whoops

Thanks for all the help everyone, my first Python program is now
working!

Keith

kagard (AT) gmail (DOT) com wrote:
Simon Forman wrote:
I got rid of the triple quote string at the start of the function, and
that cleared up the problem, though I don't know why.

>Ah, yes. The docstring for a function (or at least its first
>triple-quote) must be indented to the same degree as its statements.
>(If you're using IDLE it should have indented it for you when you hit
>return after the def statement.)
>>
>HTH,
>~Simon

Hi Simon:

Thanks. I code in VB / VBA, and use indented structure, but it's not
enforced they way it is in Python - still getting used to that. Also, I
got goofed up editing some of the code in VIM, indenting with tabs, and
then switching to IDLE, with space indentation. Whoops

Thanks for all the help everyone, my first Python program is now
working!

Keith

Tips: if you're coding with VIM, put "set expandtab" in your config
file. That way, each tab will be expanded into the corresponding number
of spaces Whatever the language, I find it always a bad idea to mix
spaces and tabs, and I prefer spaces

Pierre